My Grandson Drew His Other Grandma, But I Was Supposed to Be the Only One15 min read

I stole my grandson’s drawing off my daughter’s refrigerator on Sunday and hid it in my purse before anybody saw me do it. I thought the worst part was the extra woman he had drawn standing next to him.

Theo is six. The drawing was the usual kind for that age: four stick people in front of a brown house, all wearing the same enormous smile. There was a sun in the corner with eyelashes on it.

Mommy. Daddy. Theo.

Then, standing a little apart from the others, was a fourth person with gray marker hair and a purple dress.

Underneath, in his teacher’s neat printing, it said MY OTHER GRANDMA.

Six-year-olds dictate their labels. They do not usually come up with a phrase like that for no reason.

I am the only grandmother Theo has.

His father’s mother died before he was born. My daughter Rhiannon had told me that at least a dozen times over seven years. She passed in her sleep. There was no service because that side of the family did not do services.

I stood in Rhiannon’s kitchen and looked at the purple dress for a long time.

I knew I should put the drawing back. Instead, I folded it in half and slid it into my purse. When Rhiannon came in, I asked about her tomatoes before she could notice anything missing.

“They’re doing nothing,” she said. “All leaf, no fruit.”

“Too much nitrogen.”

“That’s what Craig says.”

“Then Craig is right for once.”

She laughed. I laughed too, although the drawing was folded against my wallet.

I kept my purse beside me and tried not to look at it.

On the drive home, I thought of every harmless explanation I could find. Maybe Theo had seen an old photograph. Maybe someone at school had mentioned another grandmother. Maybe he had used the phrase without understanding it.

But he had drawn the woman more than once. I knew that before I called his teacher. A child can make one strange picture. Repeating the same person is different.

I unfolded the paper at home. The gray hair and purple dress were still there, along with the enormous smile and the words beneath them. I felt foolish for being upset by a child’s drawing, then more foolish because I could not stop thinking about it.

On Monday, I called Theo’s school and asked to speak with Miss Adjei. When she came to the phone, she sounded warm and professional.

“Mrs. Vance, is everything all right?”

“I wanted to ask about Theo’s family drawings.”

“Oh, he’s a wonderful little artist.”

“There is a woman in the last one. Gray hair, purple dress.”

There was the smallest pause.

“He draws her most weeks,” Miss Adjei said. “Sometimes she’s holding his hand.”

I sat in my car in the school lot with the engine off. I had made the call there because I did not want Rhiannon to hear me asking questions from her own home.

“Does he say who she is?” I asked.

“He calls her his other grandma.”

“Have you asked him?”

“I did once, because I wanted to make sure I labeled it correctly. He said she has a bird.”

“A bird?”

“A green one that says his name. He was very specific about that.”

I thanked her and hung up.

Nobody invents a green bird that says your name. That is not what imaginary people have. Imaginary people have castles and dragons. Real people have a parakeet.

I sat there with the school buildings in front of me and the stolen drawing in my purse. I was embarrassed by what I had done, but not enough to throw the paper away. I needed to know whether I was looking at a child’s fantasy or an adult secret.

Tuesday, I went to Rhiannon’s house. Theo was in the yard, so I waited until he was out of earshot. Rhiannon stood at the sink with her hands in the dishwater.

“Where does Theo go on Thursdays?” I asked.

“Craig takes him to swim.”

“Every Thursday?”

“Since April.” She turned toward me. “Mom, why?”

“Because he told his teacher about a bird.”

Her hands stopped moving. She did not turn around, and for a woman who had never been able to keep a secret in her life, she held that one for about nine seconds.

“He wasn’t supposed to talk about it,” she said.

“About what?”

“Mom.”

“Rhiannon. About what?”

She turned around. Her face was already wet. She was thirty-four years old, but she looked exactly like she had at eleven, when she broke my mother’s dish and waited for me to find out.

“She isn’t dead,” she said.

The kitchen tilted.

“Craig’s mother?”

“Yes.”

“You told me she died.”

“Craig told me she died,” Rhiannon said. “For four years he told me that. I found out in April.”

She looked toward the yard before continuing.

“Mom, I found out in April and I didn’t know what to do with it. She has been asking to see Theo, and she is not, she isn’t what he said she was.”

“What did he say she was?”

“He said she was dangerous.”

“And is she?”

“She’s seventy-nine and she has a parakeet and she cries when we leave,” Rhiannon said. “That’s what she is.”

I had to sit down at my own daughter’s table. I was angry at Rhiannon for hiding it, angry at Craig for saying his mother was dead, and angry at myself for believing the story without ever asking another question.

“Why would a man do that?” I asked.

“I don’t know. I have asked him and he goes quiet and leaves the room.”

“Does he say what she did?”

“No.”

“Does he say she hurt him?”

“No.”

Rhiannon lowered herself into the chair across from me.

“That is the part that scares me,” she said. “Not her. Him going quiet.”

We sat there while Theo played outside. I could hear him moving around the yard, speaking to himself in the loose way children do when they are busy with a game.

“Tell me what happened in April,” I said.

Rhiannon rubbed at her face. She explained that Craig’s mother had contacted her and asked to see Theo. Rhiannon had expected an explanation, perhaps even a difficult one, but she had not expected to find an elderly woman living in a small yellow house with a green parakeet.

“She knew things about Theo,” Rhiannon said. “She knew what he liked and what he had been drawing. She said people had sent her photographs.”

“Did she say Craig knew where she was?”

“I don’t know. She said she had tried to reach him before.”

“And you believed her?”

“I didn’t know what to believe. That’s why I went first without Theo.”

“What did you find?”

“A woman who cried when I said I might let her meet him.”

Rhiannon looked toward the yard again.

“She didn’t ask me to take him away from Craig. She didn’t ask for anything except a chance to see him. I let her meet him, and then Theo wanted to go back.”

“Does he know she is his grandmother?”

“He knows she is his other grandma.”

The words landed badly. I had spent seven years thinking I was the only woman who held that place in his life. Now a child had recognized someone else as family while the adults had kept me outside the truth.

“Why didn’t you tell me?” I asked.

“Because Craig was saying she was dangerous, and I didn’t know if I was making a mistake.”

“You let me keep believing she was dead.”

“I know.”

“You let Theo visit her while I knew nothing.”

“I know, Mom.”

She was crying again. I wanted her to defend herself, but I also understood that she had been caught between a husband’s warning and an old woman’s request. Understanding did not make the secrecy acceptable. It only made it harder to know whom I should blame.

“Did you ask Craig for a reason?” I said.

“I did.”

“What did he say?”

“That she was dangerous.”

“Only that?”

“He said I had to stop taking Theo there.”

“And then?”

“He went quiet and left the room.”

I looked at the drawing in my purse. I had taken it because I thought it might expose a betrayal. It had exposed a gap in the family story instead.

“I want to meet her,” I said.

“Mom, no.”

“I am not asking, sweetheart.”

“You can’t just go there.”

“I’m not going without you. But I want to meet the woman Theo has been drawing every week.”

Rhiannon looked frightened.

“What if she isn’t who you think she is?”

“Then we will know more than we know now.”

“That doesn’t make it safe.”

“No. It makes it honest.”

She did not answer immediately. Finally, she said she would speak to Craig first.

That evening, she told him she was taking me to the house. He repeated that his mother was dangerous and said he did not want me involved. Rhiannon asked him what, exactly, his mother had done.

He did not answer.

“Craig,” she said, “I need more than that.”

He went quiet.

“Did she hurt you?” Rhiannon asked.

Another silence.

“Do you want me to stop taking Theo there?”

He said yes.

“Why?”

He did not explain. He left the room, as he had before.

Rhiannon told me she was still going. Craig did not agree, but he did not stop her.

On Thursday, she drove me to Delridge. The house was small and yellow, with a ramp built over the front steps. Rhiannon stayed in the car while I went up alone.

Before I could knock, I looked through the front window into the living room.

Every wall was covered. Floor to ceiling, every inch, and every single photograph was of my grandson.

There were pictures of Theo as a baby, pictures of him in what looked like school clothes, and pictures of him holding a small bag. Some appeared to have been taken from far away. Others looked as if someone had sent them to her.

Rhiannon got out of the car when she saw me standing there.

“What do you see?” she asked.

“Pictures of Theo.”

“All of them?”

“Every wall.”

She came beside me and looked through the glass. Her hand rose to her mouth.

“I didn’t know she had those.”

“Did Craig send them?”

“I don’t know.”

“Then ask her.”

Rhiannon rested her hand on the rail.

“I’m scared.”

“So am I.”

It was the sentence I had been nervous to say. I was scared of the woman inside, but I was also scared of what the truth would do to Rhiannon’s marriage and to Theo’s understanding of his family.

Rhiannon knocked. An older woman came slowly down the hallway. She had gray hair and wore a purple dress. Behind her, a green parakeet moved inside its cage.

Rhiannon stood still.

The woman opened the door.

“Rhiannon?” she said.

My daughter began to cry.

“You know who I am?”

“I know exactly who you are.”

The woman looked at me.

“And you must be Theo’s other grandmother.”

“I’m his mother’s mother,” I said.

“Yes,” she replied. “I know.”

Rhiannon wiped her face.

“Why did you let me believe you were dead?”

The woman’s expression tightened.

“I didn’t.”

“Craig told me.”

“I know.”

“Why didn’t you tell me yourself?”

“Every message I sent came back unanswered,” she said. “Every photograph I received was the only part of Theo I was allowed to have.”

Rhiannon looked past her into the living room.

“Did you take those pictures?”

“Some. Other people sent me the others.”

“Who?”

“People who knew I was his grandmother.”

The answer did not resolve everything. The photographs showed how desperately she wanted a place in Theo’s life, but wanting that place did not erase whatever had happened between her and Craig.

I asked her why he called her dangerous.

She looked down at the floor.

“I was not a good mother to him,” she said. “I will not pretend otherwise.”

Rhiannon waited.

“What did you do?”

“I was ill for a long time and unreliable. Craig was young, and he remembers what he remembers. I hurt him by not being there when he needed me. But I did not hurt Theo, and I have never tried to take him from you.”

She did not give us a diagnosis. She did not ask us to excuse her. She admitted that she had failed her son and said she understood why he might not want her near Theo. She also said that Craig had turned that painful history into a death that was not true.

The parakeet called from the living room.

The woman glanced toward the cage.

“There he is,” she said.

The bird called again.

“His name is Theo,” she added. “He learned it because I say it so often.”

Rhiannon looked at me, then back at the woman.

“Can we come in?” she asked.

The woman stepped aside.

We stayed less than an hour. Rhiannon asked questions, and the woman answered what she could. When she did not know how to answer, she said so. She did not demand that Rhiannon choose between her and Craig. She did not call herself a perfect mother.

Before we left, she asked whether Theo knew she was his grandmother.

“He calls you his other grandma,” I told her.

She lowered her eyes.

“Does he remember me?”

“He draws you every week.”

She began to cry. Rhiannon reached for her hand, and after a moment, I did too. I had expected to feel triumphant because I had found the truth. Instead, I felt the weight of all the years when the truth had been kept from everyone.

We did not bring Theo that day. Rhiannon said she needed to speak with him first, and I agreed. He was six. He could learn that the woman existed without being made responsible for the adults’ conflict.

On the drive home, Rhiannon called Craig. I heard his side only in fragments, but her words were clear.

“We went to see her.”

She listened.

“No, I didn’t take Theo.”

Another pause.

“You need to tell me what happened.”

She listened again, then shook her head.

“I’m not asking you to call her a good mother. I’m asking you to stop calling her dead.”

When the call ended, she put the phone down.

“What did he say?” I asked.

“He said he needs time.”

“Did he explain anything?”

“No.”

It was not enough. Craig’s pain, whatever its full shape, did not give him the right to rewrite a living person’s existence for his wife and child. At the same time, his mother’s admission made clear that the old wound was real. There was no clean villain in that yellow house, only people who had handled pain badly and a child who had noticed the missing person.

A few days later, Rhiannon took Theo to visit his other grandmother. She told him they were seeing someone from his drawings. She did not tell him that Craig had said she was dead. That was an adult wound, and it did not belong on a six-year-old’s shoulders.

Theo recognized the parakeet immediately.

“It says my name,” he said.

“It does,” the woman replied.

He looked around at the photographs.

“Those are all me.”

“Yes,” she said. “I missed you.”

Theo accepted the answer more easily than any of us had accepted the rest. He showed her a new picture from school. This time, he had drawn five figures: his mother, his father, himself, me and the woman in the purple dress.

The labels were crooked. The smiles were still enormous. The sun still had eyelashes.

He placed the drawing in her lap.

“I made you closer,” he said.

She covered her mouth. Rhiannon sat beside her, and I watched Theo move between the adults without understanding why the room felt so heavy. He only knew that the woman from his drawings was now standing in front of him.

I had kept the first drawing in my purse until that morning. Before we left, I gave it back to Theo and told him I was sorry I had taken it.

“Why did you take it?” he asked.

“Because I was confused.”

“Are you not confused now?”

“I still am a little.”

He considered that and nodded, as if confusion was a reasonable answer.

The family did not become fixed after one visit. Craig still has not explained everything. Rhiannon is still deciding what she can forgive and what she cannot. The visits are being handled carefully, and the adults are responsible for making sure Theo is not pulled into their disagreement.

But the central lie is no longer holding everyone apart.

Theo’s other grandmother is alive. She is seventy-nine, she lives in a small yellow house on Delridge, and she has a green parakeet that says his name. She admitted that she had failed her son, but she also got to meet the grandson who had been drawing her every week.

And I stopped calling myself the only grandmother Theo had.

THE END.

About The Author